Disclosure: HomeAppliancePicks.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. We independently research and recommend products; we may receive commissions on purchases made through our links.
Store-bought yogurt often comes loaded with added sugar, thickeners, and stabilizers that a homemade batch simply doesn’t need. The best yogurt maker takes the guesswork out of fermentation — a consistent, controlled temperature does the work that used to require a heating pad, an oven light, and a lot of trial and error, turning milk and a starter culture into thick, creamy yogurt overnight.
We compared 6 of the best yogurt maker options based on capacity, ease of use, and verified customer feedback. Our top pick is the Dash Greek Yogurt Maker — the most widely recommended model across every source we checked, with a digital LCD timer, dishwasher-safe BPA-free containers, and a rating that consistently holds above 4 stars across hundreds of verified reviews.
Quick Picks: Best Yogurt Makers at a Glance
Short on time? Here are the top picks. Scroll down for full details on capacity and features.
| Product | Price | Rating | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dash Greek Yogurt Maker | ~$25 | ⭐ 4.3/5* | Read Review → |
| Euro Cuisine Yogurt Maker (7 Jars) | ~$40* | ⭐ 4.4/5* | Read Review → |
| Cuisinart Yogurt Maker | ~$60* | ⭐ 4.3/5* | Read Review → |
| Bear Yogurt Maker (Stainless Steel) | ~$40* | ⭐ 4.5/5* | Read Review → |
| Proctor Silex Yogurt Maker | ~$25* | ⭐ 4.3/5* | Read Review → |
| Instant Pot Yogurt Function | ~$80* | ⭐ 4.6/5* | Read Review → |
*Ratings/prices marked with an asterisk are estimated — verify exact figures before publishing.
How We Compared These Yogurt Makers
We evaluated each yogurt maker on temperature consistency during fermentation, jar capacity and material, and verified customer feedback. A yogurt maker that heats unevenly — hotter at the base than at the top — produces inconsistent texture batch to batch, so we weighted temperature control heavily alongside straightforward day-to-day usability.
1. Dash Greek Yogurt Maker — Best Overall
As the best yogurt maker overall on this list, the Dash Greek Yogurt Maker is the most consistently recommended model across every source we checked — a straightforward design with a digital LCD timer, BPA-free storage containers, and a built-in strainer basket for authentic thick, Greek-style texture. All non-electric parts are dishwasher safe, and everything needed stores compactly inside the base between uses.
It works with any type of milk and just a spoonful of store-bought yogurt with active cultures to get started. One consistent piece of feedback across reviews: it heats from the bottom, so results can vary slightly if you don’t stir the culture in thoroughly before setting it to ferment.
| ✅ Pros | ❌ Cons |
|---|---|
| Most widely recommended yogurt maker across review sources | Heats from the bottom — stir culture thoroughly for even results |
| Digital LCD timer, BPA-free dishwasher-safe containers | Lid doesn’t always seal tightly for fridge storage |
| Compact all-in-one storage design |
| Capacity | Up to 2 quarts |
| Containers | BPA-free, dishwasher safe |
| Best For | Beginners, everyday Greek yogurt |
2. Euro Cuisine Yogurt Maker (7 Jars) — Best for Portion Control
The best yogurt maker pick for portion control, the Euro Cuisine ferments yogurt in 7 individual reusable glass jars — genuinely convenient for grab-and-go portions, or for making different flavors in the same batch by adding fruit or flavoring to individual jars before fermenting. Glass jars also avoid the plastic-contact question entirely for the fermenting vessel itself.
The trade-off for individual portions is less flexibility for a single large batch compared to a bulk-format yogurt maker, and the glass jars require more careful handling than plastic equivalents.
| ✅ Pros | ❌ Cons |
|---|---|
| 7 individual glass jars — genuine portion control | Less suited to one large batch than bulk-format makers |
| Glass avoids plastic contact during fermentation | Glass jars need more careful handling |
| Easy to flavor individual portions separately |
| Jars | 7 individual reusable glass jars |
| Material | Glass |
| Best For | Individual portions, grab-and-go |
3. Cuisinart Yogurt Maker — Best Multi-Function
As the most versatile best yogurt maker option here, the Cuisinart doubles as a frozen dessert maker — its double-insulated freezer bowl churns frozen yogurt, sorbet, and ice cream in under 30 minutes with no ice needed, genuinely useful if you want one appliance covering both fresh and frozen dairy treats.
The added functionality comes at a higher price than dedicated yogurt-only makers, and the freezer bowl needs advance freezing time before use for the frozen dessert function specifically.
| ✅ Pros | ❌ Cons |
|---|---|
| Doubles as a frozen yogurt, sorbet, and ice cream maker | Higher price than dedicated yogurt-only makers |
| Double-insulated freezer bowl needs no ice | Freezer bowl requires advance freezing time |
| Frozen desserts ready in under 30 minutes |
| Functions | Yogurt maker + frozen dessert maker |
| Freeze Time | Under 30 minutes for frozen desserts |
| Best For | Households wanting both fresh and frozen options |
4. Bear Yogurt Maker (Stainless Steel) — Best for Precise Control
A best yogurt maker pick built for precision, the Bear pairs a stainless steel inner pot with a built-in strainer and digital timer control, letting you dial in fermentation time precisely rather than guessing. It includes 2 one-quart glass jars, giving flexibility between a stainless steel main pot and individual glass portions in the same unit.
The digital timer control is a genuine step up in precision over basic dial-based competitors, useful for anyone who wants consistent, repeatable results batch after batch rather than relying on trial and error.
| ✅ Pros | ❌ Cons |
|---|---|
| Stainless steel inner pot plus 2 glass jars included | Higher price than basic dial-controlled makers |
| Digital timer control for precise, repeatable results | Smaller brand with fewer long-term reviews than Dash |
| Built-in strainer for authentic Greek yogurt texture |
| Inner Pot | Stainless steel |
| Included Jars | 2 x 1-quart glass jars |
| Control | Digital timer |
5. Proctor Silex Yogurt Maker — Best Budget, No-Frills Pick
This best yogurt maker option has a genuinely simple design — set it and forget it, with minimal pieces to clean afterward. Fill the pot, set the timer, and remove it once fermentation completes; there’s little else to it, which is precisely the appeal for anyone intimidated by digital controls or multiple accessories.
It lacks the individual portioning of the Euro Cuisine or the multi-function versatility of the Cuisinart, but for straightforward, no-fuss yogurt at the lowest price point on this list, it does exactly what’s needed.
| ✅ Pros | ❌ Cons |
|---|---|
| Simplest design on this list — minimal learning curve | No individual portioning or multi-function features |
| Few pieces to clean afterward | Basic dial control, no digital timer |
| Lowest price point on this list |
| Design | Single-pot, minimal accessories |
| Best For | First-time buyers, simple everyday use |
6. Instant Pot Yogurt Function — Best Multi-Purpose Upgrade
For anyone wanting a best yogurt maker pick that does more, the Instant Pot’s dedicated Yogurt function turns one appliance into both your yogurt maker and everything else it already does — pressure cooking, slow cooking, sautéing, and more. The stainless steel inner pot holds significantly more volume than a dedicated single-purpose yogurt maker.
For anyone specifically wanting a dedicated, purpose-built yogurt maker rather than a multi-function appliance, the Dash or Bear above are more focused choices — this pick makes the most sense for buyers replacing multiple kitchen gadgets with one unit.
| ✅ Pros | ❌ Cons |
|---|---|
| One appliance replaces yogurt maker plus several others | Higher price than dedicated single-purpose yogurt makers |
| Large stainless steel inner pot capacity | Bulkier countertop footprint than compact dedicated makers |
| Genuinely useful if you already want a multi-cooker |
| Type | Multi-function pressure cooker with yogurt setting |
| Inner Pot | Stainless steel |
| Best For | Replacing multiple kitchen appliances with one |
How to Choose the Best Yogurt Maker
Finding the right best yogurt maker for your household comes down to matching capacity and control style to how you actually plan to use it.
Temperature Consistency Matters More for the Best Yogurt Maker Than Any Other Feature
The single biggest factor separating a good best yogurt maker pick from a frustrating one is even, consistent heat throughout the fermentation cycle. Models that heat unevenly from the base up can produce inconsistent texture — thicker at the bottom, thinner at the top — regardless of how long you set the timer.
Individual Jars vs. One Large Batch
Individual jar systems, like the Euro Cuisine’s 7-jar design, make portion control and flavoring individual servings easy, but sacrifice flexibility if you want one large batch you can portion out later. A single large-pot design, like the Dash or Proctor Silex, is simpler for straightforward daily use.
Glass vs. Plastic vs. Stainless Steel
Glass jars, like the Euro Cuisine’s, are chemically inert during the fermentation process itself. Stainless steel, like the Bear’s inner pot, is equally non-reactive and more impact-resistant than glass. BPA-free plastic containers, common on budget models, are considered food-safe but don’t fully sidestep the material question the way glass or steel does.
Dedicated Yogurt Maker vs. Multi-Function Appliance
A dedicated yogurt maker, like the Dash or Bear, is purpose-built and typically more compact. A multi-function pressure cooker with a yogurt setting, like the Instant Pot, makes sense specifically if you’re also using it for pressure cooking, slow cooking, or sautéing — otherwise the added bulk and cost aren’t justified for yogurt alone.
Starter Culture and Milk Type
Every yogurt maker on this list works with a simple starter of store-bought plain yogurt containing live active cultures, mixed into your milk of choice. Whole milk produces the thickest, creamiest results; low-fat and non-dairy alternatives work but typically need a thickener or straining step to reach a comparable texture.
How Often You’ll Realistically Use It
A best yogurt maker pick only pays off if it fits into an actual weekly routine — most fermentation cycles run overnight, so the realistic pattern is setting a batch before bed once or twice a week rather than daily. If you’re only making yogurt occasionally, a simpler, lower-cost model like the Proctor Silex avoids over-investing in features you won’t use regularly. Frequent users making multiple batches a week benefit more from a larger-capacity or multi-jar design that reduces how often you’re restocking.
Cleanup and Long-Term Maintenance
Dishwasher-safe containers, standard on most models in this comparison, make weekly cleanup simple. The base unit itself — the part with the heating element — is typically wipe-clean only and should never be submerged. Over time, mineral buildup from milk residue can accumulate on lids and strainers; a regular soak in warm soapy water after each batch prevents this from becoming a stubborn cleaning job later.
Frequently Asked Questions About Yogurt Makers
What is the best yogurt maker overall?
The Dash Greek Yogurt Maker is the top pick — the most widely recommended model across review sources, with a digital LCD timer, BPA-free dishwasher-safe containers, and a rating that consistently holds above 4 stars.
How does a yogurt maker actually work?
A yogurt maker maintains a consistent warm temperature (typically around 108-112°F) for several hours, which is the ideal range for the live bacterial cultures in your starter to ferment milk into yogurt. Without consistent heat, fermentation is uneven or fails entirely.
Do I need a yogurt maker, or can I make yogurt without one?
You can make yogurt without one using an oven light, heating pad, or insulated cooler, but a dedicated yogurt maker removes the guesswork of maintaining consistent temperature and typically produces more reliable results batch after batch.
What milk works best in a yogurt maker?
Whole milk produces the thickest, creamiest texture. Low-fat or non-dairy milk alternatives work in any yogurt maker on this list, but often benefit from straining afterward (as with a Greek yogurt strainer) to reach a comparable thickness.
How long does it take to make yogurt in a yogurt maker?
Most models on this list take 6-10 hours to fully ferment a batch, which is why overnight use is the most common approach — set it before bed and it’s ready in the morning.
Can a yogurt maker make other foods besides yogurt?
Some can — the Cuisinart doubles as a frozen dessert maker for sorbet and ice cream, and the Instant Pot’s yogurt function is one setting within a broader multi-function pressure cooker. Dedicated models like the Dash, Bear, and Proctor Silex are built specifically for yogurt fermentation only.
How do I clean a yogurt maker without damaging the heating element?
Wipe the base unit with a damp cloth only — never submerge it in water. Removable containers, jars, and lids on most best yogurt maker picks are dishwasher safe, though a quick soak in warm soapy water after each use prevents mineral buildup from becoming stubborn over time.
Why did my yogurt turn out runny or too thin?
The most common causes are using milk that’s too low in fat, not straining long enough for Greek-style thickness, or a starter culture that’s lost potency. Whole milk and a fresh, active starter culture consistently produce the thickest results across every yogurt maker in this comparison.
Final Verdict: The Best Yogurt Maker
For most households, the Dash Greek Yogurt Maker is the best yogurt maker — the most proven, widely recommended option with a digital timer and dishwasher-safe containers. For portion control, the Euro Cuisine’s 7-jar design makes individual servings simple. And if you already want a multi-function appliance, the Instant Pot’s yogurt setting replaces several kitchen gadgets with one unit.
Whichever best yogurt maker you choose, consistent fermentation temperature matters more than any other single spec — get that right and reliable results follow every time. For more kitchen picks, see our guide to best panini press for small kitchens, or visit our Kitchen Appliances hub for more picks.